Making life
a little sweeter.
Handcrafted cookies, cupcakes, and layer cakes — made in small batches from scratch by Jenn, two neighborhoods over.
A few cakes Jenn has made lately.
Pick a path — Jenn walks you through the rest.
Shop the bakery
Cookies, cupcakes, and cookie cutters ready to ship out of the kitchen this week.
Start here
Custom cakes
Itemized builder with an AI preview rendering at the end. 50% deposit to book.
Start here
Wedding cakes
Once-in-a-lifetime cakes with a dedicated design call. Different payment schedule.
Start here
Custom cupcakes
Fondant toppers, edible images, themed piping — by the dozen.
Start here
Custom cookies
Royal-iced sugar cookies in any shape. Corporate logos, event favors, the works.
Start hereWhat folks are actually saying.
“Jennifer was amazing! I had a last minute order placed where I only gave her 3 days notice and she delivered a delicious, beautifully decorated cake that completely exceeded expectations.”
“Excellent service! The cake was beautiful and delicious — it turned out exactly how I wanted.”
“Great customer service and makes great cakes. Affordable as well. Highly recommend.”
“Ordered a cake last minute and she had it ready in less than 24 hours. Absolutely perfectly done — her customer service is wonderful.”
“I ordered a cake and chocolate-covered strawberries. They were fantastic — Bakesters did a wonderful job on both and was very easy to communicate with.”
Jenn started Bakesters in the spring of 2022.
She’d been baking for neighbors for years — birthdays, bake sales, the occasional wedding favor. When the cottage food laws in Ohio opened up, Bakesters became official.
Over the years, she’s leaned harder into the artisan side of the work — more cake sculptor than home baker. Making life a little sweeter.
Read the full story